When Python is compiled without zlib support, the error message is not very helpful when trying to untar an archive.

>>> tarfile.open('sample.tar.gz')
tarfile.ReadError: file could not be opened successfully

It happens when you run "python distribute_setup.py", for example.
 ( http://s3.pixane.com/pip_distribute.png )

Which message do you suggest?

something like :
  raise CompressionError("zlib module is not available")

If you pass an explicit mode, the error message is more or less what you want:

>>> tarfile.open("uga.tgz", mode="r:gz")
[...]
tarfile.CompressionError: gzip module is not available

The way mode="r" detects which compression format is used is to open the file with each open method (i.e. taropen, gzopen, bz2open) until one of them succeeds. If none of them matches it is impossible to say what the reason was.

As this would require more than just a simple one-line change, 2.7 is out of the question. But I see what I can do for 3.2.