Message412065
I agree that the typeshed issue is less important than the output of dir() and help(). I also agree that we shouldn't make a fetish of typing.
However, I see the typeshed issue less as an issue specific to typing, and more as an example that illustrates a general problem third-party tools have. For example, having these temporary variables leak into global namespaces also makes IDE autocompletion less valuable, and makes life harder for tools that auto-generate documentation.
Perhaps a PEP8 revision might be warranted in due course — but in the meantime, are there any downsides to this proposed change? I believe we have pointed out several upsides.
I don't see this as a style issue first and foremost: the PR is attempting to solve a genuine problem for some end-users of Python. It is not simply making cosmetic changes. |
|
Date |
User |
Action |
Args |
2022-01-29 09:29:08 | AlexWaygood | set | recipients:
+ AlexWaygood, terry.reedy, zach.ware, sobolevn |
2022-01-29 09:29:08 | AlexWaygood | set | messageid: <1643448548.19.0.962451743613.issue46565@roundup.psfhosted.org> |
2022-01-29 09:29:08 | AlexWaygood | link | issue46565 messages |
2022-01-29 09:29:08 | AlexWaygood | create | |
|