This issue tracker has been migrated to GitHub, and is currently read-only.
For more information, see the GitHub FAQs in the Python's Developer Guide.

Author sobolevn
Recipients BTaskaya, pablogsal, sobolevn
Date 2022-01-18.12:30:07
SpamBayes Score -1.0
Marked as misclassified Yes
Message-id <1642509008.04.0.395294321194.issue46422@roundup.psfhosted.org>
In-reply-to
Content
While working on https://github.com/python/cpython/pull/30058 I've noticed that `Positions` namedtuple is kinda strange, source: 
https://github.com/python/cpython/blame/8c2fd09f365e082cfceb29afdf38953cdd670946/Lib/dis.py#L204-L213

Why?
1. It is not used. `grep` shows that:

```
» ag Positions .  
Misc/HISTORY
21894:  treated as being relative to the end of the input string. Positions

Objects/codeobject.c
1021:static PyTypeObject PositionsIterator = {
1067:    positionsiterator* pi = (positionsiterator*)PyType_GenericAlloc(&PositionsIterator, 0);

Mac/PythonLauncher/English.lproj/MainMenu.nib/info.nib
7:      <key>IBEditorPositions</key>

Lib/dis.py
204:Positions = collections.namedtuple(
205:    'Positions',
239:_Instruction.positions.__doc__ = "dis.Positions object holding the span of source code covered by this instruction"
259:         positions - Optional dis.Positions object holding the span of source code

Lib/test/test_compile.py
1013:class TestSourcePositions(unittest.TestCase):

Doc/library/re.rst
1579:Finding all Adverbs and their Positions
```

2. Commenting it out does not make `test_dis` to fail (again, because it does not seem to be used)
3. It is documented (in docstrings only, not in `dis.rst`) that `Instruction.positions` is `dis.Positions`, but this is not true. Because `Instruction` is created as:

```python
co_positions = co_positions or iter(())

try:
  positions = next(co_positions)
except StopIteration:
  positions = None

Instruction(positions=positions)
```

So, it is at best is `tuple | None`. Never `Positions`.

What to do with it?
1. Should it be removed as unused, undocumented, and unreleased?
2. Should it be used as documented? Here: https://github.com/python/cpython/blame/8c2fd09f365e082cfceb29afdf38953cdd670946/Lib/dis.py#L453-L455
3. Any other ideas?

In my opinion, it is not required, because we already have `codeobject.co_positions` which is pretty much the same thing: https://docs.python.org/3.11/reference/datamodel.html?highlight=co_positions#codeobject.co_positions

I would like to work on it after a final decision is made :)
History
Date User Action Args
2022-01-18 12:30:08sobolevnsetrecipients: + sobolevn, pablogsal, BTaskaya
2022-01-18 12:30:08sobolevnsetmessageid: <1642509008.04.0.395294321194.issue46422@roundup.psfhosted.org>
2022-01-18 12:30:07sobolevnlinkissue46422 messages
2022-01-18 12:30:07sobolevncreate