Author elias
Recipients elias
Date 2018-02-28.03:10:50
SpamBayes Score -1.0
Marked as misclassified Yes
Message-id <>
Usually, a positive finite number modulo infinity is itself. But modding a positive fraction by infinity produces nan:

>>> from fractions import Fraction
>>> from math import inf
>>> 3 % inf
>>> 3.5 % inf
>>> Fraction('1/3') % inf

Likewise, a positive number modulo negative infinity is usually negative infinity, a negative number modulo infinity is usually infinity, and a negative number modulo negative infinity is usually itself, unless the number doing the modding is a fraction, in which case it produces nan.

I think fractions should behave like other numbers in cases like these. I don't think this comes up very often in practical situations, but it is inconsistent behavior that may surprise people.

I looked at the fractions module. It seems like this can be fixed by putting the following lines at the top of the __mod__ method of the Fraction class:

    if b == math.inf:
        if a >= 0:
            return a
            return math.inf
    elif b == -math.inf:
        if a >= 0:
            return -math.inf
            return a

If that is too verbose, it can also be fixed with these lines, although this is less understandable IMO:

    if math.isinf(b):
        return a if (a >= 0) == (b > 0) else math.copysign(math.inf, b)

I noticed this in Python 3.6.4 on OS X 10.12.6. If anyone wants, I can come up with a patch with some tests.
Date User Action Args
2018-02-28 03:10:51eliassetrecipients: + elias
2018-02-28 03:10:51eliassetmessageid: <>
2018-02-28 03:10:51eliaslinkissue32968 messages
2018-02-28 03:10:50eliascreate