Author p-ganssle
Recipients Anders.Hovmöller, Arfrever, Elvis.Pranskevichus, Eric.Hanchrow, Roman.Evstifeev, SilentGhost, aymeric.augustin, barry, belopolsky, berker.peksag, cben, cvrebert, davydov, deronnax, eric.araujo, flying sheep, jcea, jstasiak, jwilk, karlcow, kirpit, larsonreever, martin.panter, mcepl, mihaic, nagle, ncoghlan, p-ganssle, pbryan, perey, piotr.dobrogost, r.david.murray, roysmith, sirex, vstinner
Date 2017-12-05.00:33:52
SpamBayes Score -1.0
Marked as misclassified Yes
Message-id <1512434032.49.0.213398074469.issue15873@psf.upfronthosting.co.za>
In-reply-to
Content
> The better is the enemy of the good here.  Given the history of this issue, I would rather accept a well documented restrictive parser than wait for a more general code to be written.  Note that we can always relax the parsing rules in the future.

This is in fact the exact reason why I wrote the isoformat parser like I did, because ISO 8601 is actually a quite expansive standard, and this is the least controversial subset of the features. In fact, I spent quite a bit of time on adapting the general purpose ISO8601 parser I wrote for dateutil *into* one that only accepts the output of isoformat() because it places a minimum burden on ongoing support, so it's not really a matter of waiting for a more general parser to be written.

I suggest that for Python 3.7 we *only* support output of isoformat(). Many general iso8601 parsers exist, including the one I have already implemented for python-dateutil (which will be part of the dateutil 2.7.0 release). We can have further discussion later about what exactly should be supported in Python 3.8, but even in the pre-release discussions I'm already seeing pushback about some of the more unusual 8601 formats, and it's a *lot* easier to explain (in documentation) that `fromisoformat()` is intended to be the inverse of `isoformat()` than it is to explain which variations of ISO 8601 are and are not supported (fractional minutes? if you're following the standard, the separator has to be a T, so what other variations of the standard are allowed?).
History
Date User Action Args
2017-12-05 00:33:52p-gansslesetrecipients: + p-ganssle, barry, jcea, cben, roysmith, ncoghlan, belopolsky, nagle, vstinner, jwilk, mcepl, eric.araujo, Arfrever, r.david.murray, davydov, cvrebert, karlcow, SilentGhost, Elvis.Pranskevichus, perey, flying sheep, mihaic, aymeric.augustin, Roman.Evstifeev, berker.peksag, martin.panter, piotr.dobrogost, kirpit, Anders.Hovmöller, jstasiak, Eric.Hanchrow, deronnax, pbryan, sirex, larsonreever
2017-12-05 00:33:52p-gansslesetmessageid: <1512434032.49.0.213398074469.issue15873@psf.upfronthosting.co.za>
2017-12-05 00:33:52p-gansslelinkissue15873 messages
2017-12-05 00:33:52p-gansslecreate