Author yselivanov
Recipients brett.cannon, gvanrossum, haypo, lukasz.langa, ncoghlan, yselivanov
Date 2016-06-06.19:21:35
SpamBayes Score -1.0
Marked as misclassified Yes
Message-id <>
There is a small flaw in PEP 492 design -- __aiter__ should not return an awaitable object that resolves to an asynchronous iterator. It should return an asynchronous iterator directly.

Let me explain this by showing some examples.

I've discovered this while working on a new asynchronous generators PEP.  Let's pretend that we have them already: if we have a 'yield' expression in an 'async def' function, the function becomes an "asynchronous generator function":

   async def foo():
      await bar()
      yield 1
      await baz()
      yield 2

   # foo -- is an `asynchronous generator function`
   # foo() -- is an `asynchronous generator`

If we iterate through "foo()", it will await on "bar()", yield "1", await on "baz()", and yield "2":

   >>> async for el in foo():
   ...     print(el)

If we decide to have a class with an __aiter__ that is an async generator, we'd write something like this:

   class Foo:
      async def __aiter__(self):
          await bar()
          yield 1
          await baz()
          yield 2

However, with the current PEP 492 design, the above code would be invalid!  The interpreter expects __aiter__ to return a coroutine, not an async generator.

I'm still working on the PEP for async generators, targeting CPython 3.6.  And once it is ready, it might still be rejected or deferred.  But in any case, this PEP 492 flaw has to be fixed now, in 3.5.2 (since PEP 492 is provisional).

The attached patch fixes the __aiter__ in a backwards compatible way:

1. ceval/GET_AITER opcode calls the __aiter__ method.

2. If the returned object has an '__anext__' method, GET_AITER silently wraps it in an awaitable, which is equivalent to the following coroutine:

    async def wrapper(aiter_result):
        return aiter_result

3. If the returned object does not have an '__anext__' method, a DeprecationWarning is raised.
Date User Action Args
2016-06-06 19:21:37yselivanovsetrecipients: + yselivanov, gvanrossum, brett.cannon, ncoghlan, haypo, lukasz.langa
2016-06-06 19:21:36yselivanovsetmessageid: <>
2016-06-06 19:21:36yselivanovlinkissue27243 messages
2016-06-06 19:21:36yselivanovcreate