[This is a copy of a message posted on comp.lang.python
for which I did not see any response. After some
reflection, I began to see it as a bug in python, so
here is the bug report.]

I have a set of XML documents that use external entity
definitions for which I am having problems parsing them
using python and xml.sax. The problem is with the
resolution of relative paths in these. 
An example:

dir1/test.xml:
	<?xml version="1.0"?>
	<!DOCTYPE test SYSTEM " ../dir2/test.dtd">
	<test>&ent;</test>

dir2/test.dtd:
	<!ENTITY ent SYSTEM "test.inc">
	<!ELEMENT test (#PCDATA)>

dir2/test.inc:
	external entity test

From what I understand of XML specs, relative paths in
external entities are relative to the location of the
document *in which they are defined*. However, using
xml.sax (which calls expat, I presume), the paths are
resolved relative to the current working directory. So
the parser can not find the test.inc when the current
working directory is e.g. dir1.

I do not see how creating an EntityResolver would help
here: how do I know against what base path I have to
resolve the entity? 

(the same thing can be read without problems with other
xml parser, for instance in Java).

Bart.

Logged In: YES 
user_id=988879

See also Bugs 902037 and 616431.  -ccr-

I'll close in a couple of weeks unless someone has a good reason to keep it open.

No reply to msg114256.