This issue tracker has been migrated to GitHub, and is currently read-only.
For more information, see the GitHub FAQs in the Python's Developer Guide.

Title: Implementation for PEP 318 using syntax J2
Type: Stage:
Components: Interpreter Core Versions: Python 2.4
Status: closed Resolution:
Dependencies: Superseder:
Assigned To: Nosy List: ms_
Priority: normal Keywords: patch

Created on 2004-08-22 15:39 by ms_, last changed 2022-04-11 14:56 by admin. This issue is now closed.

File name Uploaded Description Edit
decorator.J2.200408261700.patch ms_, 2004-08-26 16:13 Patch against Anon CVS as of 2004/8/26, 17:00
Messages (5)
msg46759 - (view) Author: Michael (ms_) Date: 2004-08-22 15:39
This patch implements decorator syntax J2 from 
class Foo: 
      staticmethod deprecated memoize 
      author("Joe Bloggs") 
   def foo(bar): 
Key changes: 
   * Grammar/Grammar updated 
   * Python/compile.c updated. 
   * Test suite, docs and Lib updated. (test suite passes on my 
linux box) 
Specific changes: 
   * Grammar/Grammar changed to recognise J2 syntax 
   * Python/compile.c changed to support J2 
   * Removed "@" from Lib/ as Special 
   * Removed "AT" from joe Include/token.h as a token 
   * Removed "AT" from Parser/tokenizer.c 
   * Doc/lib/libfuncs.tex - Changed examples from @ format 
     to decorate: format 
   * Doc/ref/ref7.tex  
      - changed Function Definitions production rules to match 
        the change in syntax. 
      - Changed example to use the change in syntax. 
   * Lib/compiler/ - Modified to handle the new 
   * Lib/test/ - Changed tests for old syntax to 
check new form 
   * Lib/test/tokenize_tests.txt - changed @staticmethod to J2 
   * Lib/test/output/test_tokenize - Changed to match the 
changed test file 
   * Modules/parsermodule.c - Changed to support new 
   * Lib/test/ - Changed from @ syntax to 
decorate: syntax 
   * Lib/test/ - changed all "decorate" 
functions to 
     decorate_ and all @ usages to "decorate:" syntax. 
Files checked, but not changed: 
   * Doc/lib/asttable.tex - Can't see any necessary changes 
   * Lib/compiler/ - Can't see any necessary 
   * Lib/compiler/ - Can't see any necessary 
   * Tools/compiler/ast.txt - Can't see any necessary changes 
   * Tools/compiler/ - Can't see any necessary 
   * Tools/compiler/ - No changes 
   * I can't see whether should/should not be changed 
     if it should, *how* it should be changed, as a result I've left 
     well alone. 
   * Keyword clash with test suite is bad - suggest change to 
     to limit clash with existing user code as far as possible. 
     I intend to follow this up with a replacement with a 
     changed keyword and if possible shortened/simplified 
   * Patch is against the vanilla 2.4a2 download from, does 
     this need changing to being a patch against the current 
CVS head? 
     (I suspect the answer to this is "yes") 
   * The following tests are skipped on my machine: 
       test_aepack test_al test_applesingle test_bsddb185 
       test_cd test_cl test_codecmaps_cn test_codecmaps_hk 
       test_codecmaps_jp test_codecmaps_kr 
test_codecmaps_tw test_curses 
       test_gdbm test_gl test_imgfile test_largefile 
       test_macfs test_macostools test_nis test_normalization 
       test_ossaudiodev test_pep277 test_plistlib 
       test_socket_ssl test_socketserver test_sunaudiodev 
       test_timeout test_urllibnet test_winreg test_winsound 
     As a result I don't know for certain these aren't affected by 
     change. I'm checking them by hand at present. 
msg46760 - (view) Author: Michael (ms_) Date: 2004-08-25 20:17
Logged In: YES 

Updated patch against anonymous CVS.  
Covers the same files as before, with the addition of changes to, and was updated to handle  
the paired decorate/def blocks. Specifically this required changes  
to getblock such that if getblock is called on a decorated function  
that both blocks are returned rather than just the function or just  
the decorator suite. This is to preserve the same behaviour as the 
current inspect behaviour. 
* changed keyword to "using" 
* Eliminated the single clash in the library that uses "using" as a 
variable. ( has a function "get" that has "using" as a 
single named parameter. AFAICT no google findable source file 
uses this parameter) 
* implemented the short form: 
using: trace 
def someFunction(someThing): doStuff(someThing) 
* Decorators are single decorator per line - as per current CVS, 
which means the short form only takes 1 decorator. 
All tests except test_distutils pass. Since this appear to fail in Anon 
CVS without this patch that failure looks unrelated. 
Remaining issues(?): 
* It's been suggested that this should be activated by a __future__ 
declaration. I'm currently looking at how to do this. 
* Extra docs on short form would probably be a good idea. (Docs 
are already updated otherwise) 
msg46761 - (view) Author: Michael (ms_) Date: 2004-08-26 16:13
Logged In: YES 

msg46762 - (view) Author: Michael (ms_) Date: 2004-08-26 16:19
Logged In: YES 

The updated patch is against anon CVS as of 26 Aug 2004, 17:00.  
This patch leaves the keyword unchanged as "using". All tests 
pass on my machine (with "make testall"). 
The key change is that the keyword - and hence decorators must 
now be actively switched on using a "from __future__ import 
decorators" statement. The code using this is heavily based on the 
same approach that "from __future__ import generators" took  -- 
indeed reusing as much as possible.  
I suspect that it might be wise to have more tests regarding 
decorators, and the docs might need a small amount of work, any 
feedback welcome on this point. 
msg46763 - (view) Author: Michael (ms_) Date: 2004-09-01 09:32
Logged In: YES 

Guido wrote: 
"I've read the J2 proposal up and down several times, pondered all 
the issues, and slept on it for a night, and I still don't like it 
enough to accept it." 
I'm closing this patch as a result, I hope that's the right thing to 
Date User Action Args
2022-04-11 14:56:06adminsetgithub: 40802
2004-08-22 15:39:51ms_create